top of page

Where Do I Belong? Who Do I Believe? What Do I Follow?

2 days ago
6 min read

A Pilates teacher's reflection on tradition, science and the art of movement. by Mariann


The longer I teach Pilates, the more questions I seem to have. Interestingly, the more I educate myself, the less inclined I am to believe that there is only one correct way of doing things.

Recently, I have found myself questioning where I belong within the Pilates world. Classical Pilates? Contemporary Pilates? Physiotherapy-informed Pilates? Or somewhere in between?


Coming from a sporting background, I am deeply rooted in the principles of alignment, breathing, concentration, precision and core control. These are fundamental to my teaching, and I have enormous admiration for what Joseph Pilates created.

Yet, as our understanding of the human body continues to evolve, I find myself increasingly curious about the relationship between his original method and modern movement science.


The beauty of classical Pilates

There is something quite extraordinary about watching someone perform the classical Pilates repertoire beautifully. The precision, strength, coordination, breathing and seamless transitions between exercises are remarkable.

Joseph Pilates did not simply create a collection of exercises. He created a method, a carefully organised repertoire of movements intended to be practised and refined over time.

From a motor learning perspective, this makes a great deal of sense. Repetition allows our nervous system to become increasingly efficient at organising movement. The more familiar we become with an exercise, the more attention we can devote to its finer details.

With my sporting background, I can relate to this enormously. I can also appreciate its application within the world of dance, where precision, coordination and mastery of movement are particularly important.


In many ways, I see classical Pilates as comparable to a sporting discipline. You develop the physical capabilities required to perform a specific repertoire and, through consistent practice, become increasingly accomplished at it.


There is something beautiful about this pursuit of mastery.

But it also raises a question for me.


Is becoming exceptionally good at performing Pilates necessarily the same as becoming more physically capable in everyday life?


Are we training for Pilates or training for life?


This is where I begin to question my own position.

The majority of people who attend my classes are not necessarily looking to master the classical repertoire. They want to become stronger, improve their balance, maintain their independence and feel more confident in their ability to move.

They want to play golf, walk in the hills, work in their gardens, pick up their grandchildren or simply get off the floor more comfortably.

I want them to develop neuromuscular control, muscular strength, concentration, coordination and proprioception — our awareness of where our body is in space.


Pilates provides an excellent foundation and frame for developing these qualities, but I also want to explore how we can challenge them further.

What happens when we introduce an unstable surface, change the direction of resistance, challenge balance or introduce a less familiar movement pattern?

Can we take a recognisable Pilates exercise, retain its fundamental principles, and introduce an additional proprioceptive or coordination challenge that has relevance to everyday life?

Life, after all, does not present us with a predetermined sequence of movements. It is unpredictable, multidirectional and constantly changing.

Our ability to adapt to those demands is, for me, an essential component of physical fitness.


The individual before the repertoire


I teach around 16 - 22 Pilates classes every week.

Do I follow exactly the same sequence in each of them? No.

Do I have a structured plan, a clear objective and a foundation around which each class is built? Absolutely.

However, what happens around that structure often depends on the group in front of me and sometimes simply on who walks through the door that morning.

Imagine a fictional client, Atlantis, who has recently fractured a rib. His physiotherapist has cleared him to return to appropriate exercise, but certain movements, such as rolling through his spine or performing side lying or side plank, remain unsuitable at this stage of his recovery.

Should he be excluded from participating because he cannot perform parts of my planned repertoire?

Or can I adapt the session, within the guidance of his physiotherapist, so that he can continue to benefit from appropriate physical activity?

One of the things I enjoy most about teaching Pilates is the creativity it allows me. Thinking on my feet, observing movement, recognising compensatory strategies and knowing when to progress, regress, modify or replace an exercise.

I do not believe that this makes my teaching any less rooted in Pilates.

For me, it is about understanding the principles sufficiently well to apply them to different individuals, rather than simply knowing how to teach a sequence of exercises.


What Joseph Pilates could not have known

Joseph Pilates was remarkably forward-thinking. His observations about habitual movement patterns, muscular imbalances, compensations, breathing and physical conditioning were impressive for his time.

However, Joseph was not a medical doctor, and much of our current understanding of biomechanics, neuroscience, pain and rehabilitation was developed after his lifetime.

We now understand that postural variations do not necessarily cause pain. Muscular imbalances do not automatically lead to injury. Asymmetry is not always something that requires correction.

Pain is a considerably more complex phenomenon than a purely mechanical problem.


Does this mean that alignment is unimportant? Certainly not. Alignment remains a fundamental part of my teaching.

However, there is a difference between understanding alignment, developing control over movement and assuming that there is one ideal alignment that everyone must achieve.

Sometimes a compensatory movement is an effective adaptation rather than a problem that needs correcting.


Sometimes a compensatory movement is an effective adaptation rather than simply a problem that needs correcting.

Consider someone who has undergone a Caesarean section or another form of abdominal surgery. Changes in the abdominal wall and neuromuscular recruitment can influence muscular coordination, breathing and movement patterns.

How do I know this? Because I have had a Caesarean section myself.

A classical Roll Up may look different as a result. Does it require attention, guidance and gradual correction? Absolutely. But understanding why someone moves differently is equally important.

There is also a psychological element to our teaching. Helping clients understand why their bodies have adapted, reassuring them that improvement is possible and giving them confidence in their ability to rebuild strength and function are just as valuable as correcting the movement itself.

Understanding the history of the body in front of me is just as important as understanding the exercise I am teaching.


As teachers, we have the opportunity to combine Joseph's remarkable observations with decades of subsequent scientific discoveries.

Why would we not embrace that opportunity?


Was Joseph right about a set sequence?


This is where my curiosity brings me back to classical Pilates.

There is a compelling argument for practising a consistent repertoire. Familiarity allows us to refine movement, observe progress, develop neuromuscular control and gradually reduce the cognitive demands of learning new exercises.

There is enormous value in repetition.

Perhaps the question is not whether a set sequence is beneficial, but whether every individual is adequately prepared to perform it.


Could we first develop the necessary foundations of strength, mobility, coordination and control through individually appropriate exercises, before progressing towards a more established repertoire?

Equally, modern motor learning research suggests that introducing variability into practice can help develop adaptability and the transfer of learned skills into different environments.

This interests me enormously because it suggests that both consistency and variation have a valuable place in movement education.

Perhaps they are not opposing philosophies at all.


The danger of Pilates bias


As Pilates teachers, I believe we must also be conscious of our own professional bias.

When we become passionate about a particular method, it is easy to become attached not only to its exercises but also to its explanations, traditions and beliefs.

We may begin to interpret everything through the lens of Pilates, overlooking evidence that challenges what we have been taught.

And this applies equally to classical and contemporary Pilates teachers.

I love Pilates, but loving a method does not mean that I have to believe it is superior to every other form of exercise. Nor does it mean accepting every historical explanation of why it works.

There should be no embarrassment in questioning something we have previously believed or adapting our teaching when new evidence becomes available.

We should remain curious, open-minded and willing to learn from physiotherapists, sports scientists, exercise professionals and other movement disciplines.

Education should challenge our beliefs, not merely reinforce them.


So, where do I belong?


Perhaps I do not need to belong exclusively to either school of thought.

I can appreciate the beauty of classical Pilates, respect its repertoire and remain deeply rooted in its principles, whilst embracing contemporary exercise science, physiotherapy research and the individuality of human movement.

I can value repetition without sacrificing creativity. I can teach precision whilst encouraging adaptability. I can respect tradition without being afraid to question it.


Perhaps the best way to honour Joseph Pilates and his extraordinary legacy is not simply to preserve everything he taught, but to continue doing what he himself did so remarkably well: observing, questioning, exploring and innovating.


For me, the greatest measure of success is not necessarily how beautifully someone performs a Pilates exercise in my class, but how the skills they develop there translate into their everyday life.

After all, Joseph himself believed that the benefits of Pilates should extend beyond the studio and into everyday life.

And perhaps, despite all my questions and reflections, that is precisely where Joseph and I meet.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page